Whose clock are we using? UNAM academic challenges how African universities measure success

What if a university slipped down the global rankings while becoming more useful to the people it serves? Would that really be decline?

That is the question Dr. Manfred Janik, Senior Lecturer in Psychology and Social Work at the University of Namibia, puts to African higher education in his essay, “Going Down According to Whose Standards?”

Debates on decolonising universities usually focus on curriculum, language, representation and Indigenous knowledge. Dr. Janik argues that the idea of “competitiveness” deserves the same scrutiny.

“Why do universities in Africa so readily adopt the increasingly global assumption that better must mean not only more, but also faster?” he asks.

Rankings tell only part of the story

Namibian universities increasingly describe themselves through rankings. NUST recently highlighted its top national position in the Times Higher Education Impact Rankings, while UNAM points to its place in the Times Higher Education World University Rankings.

“There is nothing wrong with celebrating achievement,” Dr. Janik writes. “But the claims invite a question … according to whose standards, and according to which understanding of excellence, is one university ‘better’ than another?”

He is clear that standards matter. “Decolonisation should never become an excuse for weak scholarship,” he stresses. The harder question is whether Namibian universities merely comply with indicators developed elsewhere, or help define what quality means in their own context.

Drawing on rankings researchers such as Simon Marginson, he notes that rankings reveal research intensity, reputation and visibility. They reveal far less about whether a university supports students from disadvantaged schools, solves problems in nearby communities or changes practice in a Namibian school or clinic.

The San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA) and the Leiden Manifesto make a similar case against judging scholarship mainly by journal prestige and citations.

Competition is not the problem

Dr. Janik does not dismiss competition as “un-African”. Citing historian Kathryn de Luna and researchers Zidaru and Hopkinson, he points out that African history is full of competition for status, cattle, livelihoods and recognition.

“The more interesting question is: what kind of competition are we rewarding?”

Today’s university competition, he argues, is tied to market-based thinking, with success measured in outputs, citations and rankings: “I am successful because I have more than you. My university is excellent because it is ranked above yours.”

Slow does not mean behind

The same questions apply to time. Reports are urgent, outputs must grow, degrees must finish on schedule and funding cycles are short.

Dr. Janik draws on German sociologist Hartmut Rosa’s theory of social acceleration, and on the “slow scholarship” movement of geographer Alison Mountz and colleagues, who argue that neoliberal universities squeeze the time for thinking, teaching and mentoring.

“Trust takes time. Mentorship takes time. Listening takes time,” he writes. “A scholar who spends years building trust in a rural community may be doing work of profound public value, even if that work produces articles more slowly.”

He even finds a playful Namibian prompt in the name of Slowtown Coffee Roasters. “Slow does not always mean inefficient, unambitious or behind. Sometimes it means giving something the time required to do it properly.”

This is no excuse for lateness or poor administration, he cautions. “Faster is not always better. Some things require urgency; other things require time. Wisdom lies partly in knowing the difference.”

The person behind the work

Dr. Janik turns to Ubuntu and African ideas of relational personhood, citing Munyaradzi Murove, Augustine Nwoye and Yusef Waghid’s Towards an Ubuntu University. In Oshindonga, he notes, uuntu womuntu aantu expresses humanity realised through other people.

He also reflects on the death of Professor Jason Arday in August 2026, after public scrutiny of allegations about his academic work, which he had contested and which were still under investigation. Drawing no conclusions while an inquest is under way, Dr. Janik highlights the University of Cambridge’s observation that “there is a person at the centre of this situation”.

“Judging work should never require us to forget the humanity of the person whose work is being judged,” he writes.

Widening the meaning of excellence

An Ubuntu-informed university, he suggests, would ask whether it preserves human dignity, helps students from unequal backgrounds flourish, produces knowledge communities can use, and prepares graduates “only to compete, or also to contribute”.

Rigour still matters. “A university that is locally relevant but intellectually careless serves nobody well,” he writes. “But neither does a university that gains international prestige while becoming disconnected from the society around it.”

The task, he concludes, is to widen the meaning of global excellence, not reject it. African universities should publish internationally and compete confidently, while asking, as scholars such as Mahmood Mamdani have, whether the rules reflect their own histories and priorities.

“A university should not merely ask, ‘Are we better than them?’ It should also ask, ‘Are we becoming more useful, more just, more humane and more responsive to the society that sustains us?’”

“And perhaps one question more,” he adds. “Whose clock are we using?”

Download Dr. Janik’s full essay, with references here: | mjanik@unam.na

Recommended For You

About the Author: Simon Namesho